The morning after trick-or-treating as a child, after our mother had the opportunity to inspect our candies for malicious poisons, illicit tampering, and to sneak a few from our bags like the fantastic Midwestern mother she is, my sister and I would be handed our neon orange pumpkins filled to the brim. Filled with childish excitement, we would rush to the living room carpet amid urgent orders from our mother to eat only one and spill our bounty all over the floor for sorting and trading. As long as I can remember, the color fruit flavored Tootsie chews had been scattered among the other treats.
Among the trading and sorting of our post-Halloween excursion, there was certainly a not-at-all-subjective grading system for those colorful rolls in my child self’s eyes. That system can also be seen in use today as I leave certain colors in the bag they came in and consume others almost immediately. Below I have ranked the five flavors of the fruit flavored Tootsie chews.
This is only considering the basic five fruit flavored Tootsie chews and not the standard Tootsie roll, other assorted fruit flavors from over the years, nor any other Tootsie products. Please let me know if you agree with my ranking below!
#5 – Vanilla Flavored Chew
Walking through a Yankee candle store, sniffing every available candle on the shelves, I’ve never had the urge to eat a single one of them. However, I’m positive if I had ever given it a go, the vanilla scented one would taste eerily similar to the vanilla flavored Tootsie chew. This ivory roll wrapped in a deceptive blue wrapper even looks a bit like candle wax. Well, wax that’s been soaking in imitation vanilla extract for roughly sixteen years. Eating them is a bit like cooking with vanilla extract, actually. You think at first that you might need a bit more, but it turns out that the first was far more than enough already. Thank you vanilla chew for being the only one that neither my sister nor I really wanted to touch.
Image from Tootsie Roll Industries via tootsie.com#4 – Lemon Flavored Chew
While I could understand being confused by the blue wrapper on the vanilla chew as a child, but I don’t understand why my child self avoided this one thinking that it was vanilla since the wrapper is lemon and brown. This pale yellow treat tastes a bit more like a lemon animal cracker than a proper lemon, which is perfectly fine in the context of a candied dessert. The lemon taste is a bit muted to me, but after sharing a bite with the sweet young lady I was babysitting the other day (thanks Georgie!), it was enough to make her five-year-old palette pucker. It did leave a strange aftertaste and texture in my mouth for a while after eating that was incredibly unpleasant, so for that reason, it’s further down on this list.
Image from Tootsie Roll Industries via tootsie.com
#3 – Orange Flavored Chew
This chew, and anything else remotely orange flavored, was my resolute favorite when I was young. If ten-year-old me had been handed a bag of these, a bottle of Sunkist, and a bowl of orange Jell-O, I would have done anything you asked. Except, perhaps, my math homework. However, as an adult, I find this once favored orange cylinder of perfection to no longer be so perfect. It actually rings far too sweet and I’m no longer able to taste as much of the orange I remembered so much as I am pure sugar. Come to think of it, I don’t care for Sunkist or orange Jell-O anymore. Is it possible to have too much of a good thing?
Image from Tootsie Roll Industries via tootsie.com
#2 – Cherry Flavored Chew
If there are any die-hard cherry flavored fans out there, a little caution might be in order as this candy probably isn’t for you. I say this as someone who vehemently dislikes anything flavored or even remotely tasting of cherry. On instinct, when I bought a pack of these to try again for this article, I picked out all of the red colored ones assuming that after I tried it, I would be passing it on to my coworkers as I do most other red and pink fruit flavored candies. Imagine my surprise when I tried it and not only didn’t immediately dislike it, but actually enjoyed it enough to stick that pile in my little treat container.
Why do I advise caution for fans of cherry? Cherry flavored candies tend to be incredibly fruity while either being overwhelmingly sour, intensely sweet, or just plain bitter (think cough syrup). This candy had none of the bitterness and the sweet and sour flavor was balanced quite nicely with each other, rather than being one or the other. A side note is this was the only candy to turn my mouth a different color (a washed out red) and left a waxy film on my tongue afterward.
Image from Tootsie Roll Industries via tootsie.com
#1 – Lime Flavored Chew
If you’ve ever had a lime flavored Popsicle, this candy tastes exactly like that melted down into a candy form. Considering that is my preferred Popsicle, it’s no surprise that it tops this list. The taste is sweet enough to be a satisfying sweet treat but sour enough to not leave you feeling too guilty. It also didn’t leave a strange aftertaste, odd feeling, or turn my mouth a different color. All three extra credit points earned. Be assured if you’re ever visiting my home and see these candies in the public sweet container on my coffee table, know that the bright green colored rolls won’t be there no matter how hard you look. They’re hidden away in a cupboard for me to hoard.
Image from Tootsie Roll Industries via tootsie.com
As always, thank you for reading this far and I hope you're all staying safe! If you have any opinions on what was discussed today, as lighthearted as it was, please let me know and have a great weekend.










