1989
was a revolutionary album for Taylor Swift’s career and an instant
pop culture sensation when it fully dropped into the public’s music
libraries in October of 2014. Considered to be Swift’s first “full
pop” album, it was the final destination in a four album long
journey to that point with each album getting progressively less
country and more pop influenced. Swift had seen large scale success
with her previous ventures but nothing yet like she received with
1989
considering
chart position, sales, critical acclaim and awards.
1989
is
also much loved by her fan base who
refer to themselves as “Swifties”,
most of whom didn’t seem to mind that their country princess was
putting down the bedazzled
guitar
and
cowboy boots in
favor of a
synthesizer and strapped heels.
As someone who has been a fan of Swift since 2008, I was delighted
to
find that I immediately loved the album,
a love which has continued to flourish as the years have continued. I
have been listening to 1989 more than I have been in recent months
and I feel I have a pretty good understanding of where I stand with
the songs on the tracklisting.
The
methodology
for this list is I would like to take the 13 tracks off of the
standard album and rank them according to my own personal preferences
from
where that stands now.
The three bonus tracks and voice
memos off of the deluxe editions will not be taken into consideration
at the current time. I
will also not be placing the accompanying music videos into my
analysis of the songs.
As always, I clarify that
this is my own personal opinion and not meant to offend, persuade, or
otherwise influence the opinions of others. I would love to hear your
own though and see how well we match up, so please let me know if the
comments below! Please know that my criticisms come from a place of
love and fun and that there isn’t a single song on this album that
I haven’t enjoyed at some point over the course of the last five
and a half years.
#13
– “Bad Blood”
This eighth track off of the
album was immediately shredded by media and fans alike upon its
release as they tried to figure out who the song was about. Swift is
notorious about keeping the subject of her inspiration quiet, despite
the little hints she’ll lay out like bread crumbs for her fans to
find, and this one was no different. She indeed noted that the song
was about the loss of friendship and a celebrity who did something
really nasty to her, but refused to point the finger at Katy Perry, a
singer she had a longtime feud with, despite the media touting it
across headlines.
This song is one that I find I
can’t listen to unless I’m supremely upset, at which point it
does its job well. The angry, revenge oriented melody really help me
fan out those feelings of betrayal and rage whenever they should
arise. Unfortunately for “Bad Blood”, the clunky chorus and
lackluster bridge make the song unpleasant for a casual background
listen. For this reason, it finds itself occupying the bottom slot of
my list.
Favorite Lyric : “...salt
in the wound like you’re laughing right at me.”
#12 – “How You Get
the Girl”
“How
You Get the Girl” is a track that lyrically is, in Swift’s own
words, written “...like a tutorial. If you follow the directions in
the song, chances are things will work out. Or you may get a
restraining order.” I always liked her explanation as it perfectly
sums up my feelings around the song. I always imagined Swift sitting
with a male friend on the couch and feeding him these lyrics as
relationship counseling. On the one side of the coin, it’s an
upbeat, cute tune torn from the fabric of romantic comedy climaxes
but on the other side, it can be seen as problematic.
I
think we’ve all had to come to the realization after adolescence
that things that are cute in films can be just downright odd when
performed out in real life. While enjoying this song, I can’t help
that nagging voice in the back of my mind that drags fingernails down
my subconscious about how equal
parts cute and weird I would find most of the scenes that played out
like the ones in these films. It’s adorable and romantic on paper
to have a significant other you’ve had a falling out with show up
in the rain to profess their love for you. In real life, I think I’d
be more annoyed than anything.
Favorite Lyric : “Broke
your heart, I’ll put it back together. I want you forever and
ever.”
#11 – “Welcome to
New York”
My first listen of 1989,
I had only heard
“Shake It Off” and “Blank Space” leading up to the release.
Despite “Welcome to New York” coming out a week before the album,
I had refrained from listening to it. It was close enough to the
album release date, I felt I could wait so the day the album came
out.
That Monday, I got home
from work so late that it was pitch black outside. I locked myself in
my room, put my headphones on and sat in the dark as I listened to
the album, a really strange tradition of mine as I like to “see”
the music in the dark, what stories they’ll tell. Immediately upon
listening to this I was
struck with the imagery of red, pink and orange neon lights forming
the words shining around all of the other pictures she was painting
for the listener.
If I would have been handed
the lyrics on paper and told to read them, I would have said it could
never be a song I could enjoy, and I probably wouldn’t like it as
much as I do now if I hadn’t introduced myself to it the way I did.
The images I formed that night, while probably proving some level of
insanity, also forever embedded themselves to the memory of the song.
“Welcome to New York” may not be my favorite song about New York
(“New York Groove”, all day), but I have a special place in my
heart for it nonetheless.
Favorite Lyric :
“...kaleidoscope of loud heartbeats under coats.”
#10 – “All You Had
to Do Was Stay”
I
hate that this song has to occupy a numbered slot so far down on the
list. I feel like it doesn't quite capture just how much I love this
song, but in comparison to the others, no matter how much I might
enjoy it, it doesn't compare nor did it have the impact on my life
like some of the others. "All You Had to Do Was Stay" is a
number that gives the person Swift is singing to the what for on what
they could have had and lost due to their own actions. All they would
have had to do was, you guessed it, stay.
It's
not the most lyrically complex tune, especially compared to many in
the rest of Swift's discography, but the repetative chorus not only
makes it a song easy to nod to but begs the listener to sing along.
For such an angry, even bitter, piece its tone is shocking in its
cheerfulness. That sort of contradiction works well for music such as
this as it leaves the song available to all kinds of moods.
Favorite
Lyric : "...now you say you want it back now that it's just too
late."
#9
– “Shake It Off”
Arguably
the biggest of Swift's songs and one of the songs that even a non-fan
has a pretty good chance of having heard at one point or another,
"Shake It Off" is one of Swift's classic songs to the
haters that she seems to include on every album since 2010's Speak
Now
with "Mean". "Shake It Off" was the first song of
Swift's to scream from the rooftops in New York that she was no
longer the sweet curly haired country girl. The song's message
applies to anyone who has ever felt the need to just brush the
comments and criticisms aside.
A
mainstay on my work out playlist, "Shake It Off" has fallen
so far down on the list due to being up against stiff competition and
the amount it was played from 2014-2015.
It’s a great pep song at the end of a long hard day or for pumping
up before a night out.
Favorite
Lyric : “It’s
like I got this music in my mind saying ‘It’s gonna be alright’.”
#8 – “This Love”
“This Love” is a song that
I let sit on my playlist with the rest of the album without ever
really listening closely to it until just a year or so ago, where I
fell deeply in love with it. There are times it feels like its
falling into the pit of its own attempts to be deep, but those
moments are times when high school me fell in love with Swift and
that love continues. Who hasn’t had those moments where we were so
emotionally charged we wished we could all talk in cryptic and vague
metaphors like we do on our Facebook timelines and Twitter feeds.
And, boy, is this song emotionally charged and a perfect
representation of how we can feel conflicting things during the
course of a relationship.
It may not be a bop like some
of the others on this list, but I would scream the words at the top
of my lungs with tears streaming down my blotchy puffed face if I
lived alone. It’s in these softer songs that we really get to see
the best that Swift’s music genius has to offer.
Favorite Lyric : “These
hands had to let it go free and this love came back to me.”
#7 – “Clean”
Another song I didn’t much
care for when I’d first heard it back in 2014, I later developed a
deep appreciation and respect for it as it came to me just when I
needed it like it was a milkshake in The Good Place. Lyrics charged
with intensity, “Clean”’s backing vocals courtesy of Imogen
Heap sound at first like the breath before a sob but can later be
interpreted like the sharp sigh of relief after gaining the ability
to breathe again which perfectly reflects against Swift’s still
harsh but satisfied voice.
The parallel of recovering
from heartbreak like an addict from an addiction hits right where it
hurts when you’re already down. It’s just not a song I would
listen to often, saving it for those moments where I really need a
good cry, which is why its so far down on the list. Beautiful, a bit
haunting, and reserved for those memories we almost wish hadn’t
happened, good and bad.
Favorite Lyric : “...when
I was drowning that’s when I could finally breathe.”
#6 – “Blank Space”
A song that garnered headlines
like Buzzfeeds “Why ‘Blank Space’ is the best song on Taylor
Swift’s 1989” and has been called “the best song of
Swift’s career”, “Blank Space” will hold a significant place
in pop culture history. Amid a strong showing in the music industry
of 2014, “Blank Space” managed to carve its own legacy within
the other culture phenoms of that year such as Mark Ronson’s “Uptown Funk”, Sam
Smith’s “Stay With Me”, and Iggy Azalea’s “Fancy”. The
music scene in 2014 was a loud and colorful place.
If I was asked to sing any
Taylor Swift song at the drop of a hat, “Blank Space” would
probably be one of my first go-to’s simply because the song’s
opening lines and beat are easy to remember and the rest of the song follows
easily. That’s not to take away from the incredible visuals Swift
is able to conjure with her descriptions of seemingly simple things
(“cherry lips, crystal skies...”). Her tongue in cheek take on
the media’s image of her as a lover is an undeniable bop and one
that will certainly be in the top portion of lists ranking her best
songs for years. Unfortunately for “Blank Space”, this list isn’t
ranking her best but my personal favorites so it just misses the top
5.
Favorite Lyric : “Cause,
darling, I’m a nightmare dressed like a daydream.”
#5 – “Out of the
Woods”
“Out of the Woods” reminds
me a lot of a song from Swift’s Red album, “All Too Well”.
Retrospectively crooning about a failed relationship in the verses
and reflecting on the feelings of trepidation and caution in the
throes of a rocky but passionate love. The song received seemingly
universal acclaim from critics and fans alike upon its release. Fans
enjoyed the easy to sing lyrics and emotional overtones while critics
praised the 80’s-meets-modern sound and darker pop feeling from its
predecessor “Shake It Off”.
Once again Swift is able to
beautifully conjure images with just a few lyrics with her songs
creating a whole new world for this song to exist in that isn’t
touched by this one. Almost dream-like verses setting the scene of
the beautiful parts of the relationship while Swift’s heartbroken
vocals belie those happy feelings. Her anxiety laden words in the
chorus and rather angry bridge really capture all sides of grieving a
broken down romance.
Favorite Lyric : “The
rest of the world was black and white but we were in screaming
color.”
#4 – “I Wish You
Would”
An underrated song that is
consistently drowned out by its louder, more colorful, or more
emotional cousins, “I Wish You Would” is a fun foot tapper that
also tells a really compelling story. After a relationship has fallen
apart and the couple have gone their separate ways, the story stays
with the singer as they lament the loss, how much they just want
their lover to come back, and how they didn’t want it to end the
way it did. This is almost the opposite of “Out of the Woods”
where the more sad lyrics are instead juxtaposed against a lively,
almost cheerful beat.
I’ve loved this song since
the moment I heard it. When I listen to it, I’m sure to be humming
the bridge for hours.
Favorite lyric : “I wish
you knew that I miss you too much to be mad anymore...”
#3 – “Style”
Arguably the Swift bop to end
all bops, “Style” has had fans screaming the chorus since the
moment it debuted in 2014. The day Swift stops painting scenes with
her music is the day she’ll lose her greatest talent. Her breathy
vocals in the verses and pre-chorus cast a gentle glow against a song
that is incredibly confident in its delivery of the chorus. Swift has
become noted for her ability to craft a masterful bridge, but this
song is just the words “take me home” x3 and boy, does it work in
her favor. A song packed with stunning imagery, the climatic release
of shouting those three words elevates the song to another and much
needed level.
A song that has been called
pop perfection on an album remarked to the same elevation, we slip
“Style” into a well deserved 3rd place, coincidentally
the same slot as its track listing.
Favorite lyric : “You got
that James Dean daydream look in your eye and I got that red lip
classic thing that you like...”
#2 – “I Know Places”
The ultimate song on 1989
which, in my humble opinion, doesn’t get the love it deserves, “I
Know Places” is a gem. The darker intense feeling to the song and
the cinematic quality of the lyrics lead the whole thing to a place
of elegance and glam us mere mortals can only aspire to. The song is
inspired by Swift (and other celebrities like her) having to hide
their relationships from all forms of peering eyes lest their entire
relationship be destroyed. It’s a song that should feel out of
touch, but is done in such a passionate and loving way, I can’t
help but love it. It’s the song of a thousand Hollywood fantasies.
And the drums in this song are just absolute fire.
Favorite lyric : “Loose
lips sink ships all the damn time. Not this time.”
#1 – “Wildest
Dreams”
What is there to be said about
this song that hasn’t already been said?
Remember how I said I love a
story in a song? The more cinematic the better? Well, this song is
the epitome on 1989. It’s vague in the perfect places for
listener interpretation but deliciously specific enough to keep the
listeners interest. Never once listening through this song did I
wonder who it was about because I was so damned captivated by the
sultry vocals and reminiscence. Swift tends to play the part of the
shy lover well, but here her confidence is on full display as she
practically demands of her lover to remember her after their romance
has ended, something she knew would happen all along.
It’s a beautiful track and
there’s really nothing else to hash out. While there are a few out
there who the song didn’t mesh with, the consensus seems to be a
deep appreciation and even admiration for this song. One that
continues to grow as the years live on. When this song came out in
2014, I loved it, but it was out shined by its sisters with louder
voices and more forceful messages. Even on the music station at work,
this song is played above all other songs on 1989 and it is
for good reason.
“Wildest Dreams” will
continue to live on as one of Taylor’s shining examples of song
writing on a near perfect pop album.
Favorite Lyric : “Someday
when you leave me, I’d bet these memories follow you around.”